Using Recycled Edwards Water

Use of recycled water from sewage treatment plants can defer large amounts of Edwards Aquifer pumpage during critical times, thereby helping to maintain springflow levels and preserve endangered species habitats. There are plenty of uses that do not require potable Edwards water, such as for irrigation of golf courses and parks, air conditioning cooling towers, and industrial processes. Recycled water contains small amounts of nutrients, so using it in irrigation can reduce fertilizer costs. In other applications such as cooling towers and industrial processes, some treatment and chemical additions may be required, but such is usually the case when potable water is used.

Although reuse can reduce Edwards pumping, it can also impact downstream users and ecosystems by reducing the flow in streams that otherwise would have received the effluent, so careful consideration of all impacts is warranted. Use of recycled water in Texas is classified as either direct, such as by direct delivery from the treatment plant through a pipeline, or indirect, such as delivered via the bed and banks of a river.

Reuse In San Antonio: A Long History

Few places in the United States have practiced reuse of wastewaters longer than San Antonio. As early as 1894, raw sewage was widely used in agriculture in fields south of town. By 1901, Mitchell Lake had been constructed to capture excess flows that could not be used. By the 1930s, a wastewater treatment plant had been constructed, and both raw and partially treated effluents continued to be delivered to farmlands and to Mitchell Lake through a network of ditches.

In the 1960s, San Antonio pioneered an innovative use of recycled water in power production. After the drought of record in the 1950s, city leaders looked for ways to conserve potable Edwards supplies. Victor Braunig, then-general manager of City Public Service, the city's electrical generating utility, envisioned that large amounts of potable water could be saved if wastewater effluent was used to cool the city's power plants. Braunig Lake, first filled in 1963, was the world's first large-scale attempt to use recycled water for cooling electrical generating plants. Initially there were some problems with algae and suds from high-phosphate detergents, and large balls of soapy foam were said to have blown across I-37 like tumbleweeds. But Braunig and his staff were determined to make it work, and it ended up working so well that Calaveras Lake was built in 1969. Braunig Lake covers 1,350 acres, and Calaveras Lake covers 3,550. In dry years, up to about 40,000 acre-feet of cooling water is consumed that would otherwise have to be drawn from potable supplies. The use is classified as indirect, and CPS withdraws the recycled water from a pump station on the San Antonio River after it is released by SAWS' plants.


City Public Service Cooling Lakes

In the 1960s, City Public Service constructed two reservoirs on the southeast side of town to capture recycled water and use it for cooling power plants.

Mitchell Lake is not a cooling lake - it was part of an earlier reuse scheme in which raw and partially treated effluents were widely used in agriculture.

 

The Nation's Largest Reuse System

In 2000, the San Antonio Water System completed construction of the nation's largest recycled water distribution system. It's purpose is to move fully treated wastewater to locations where it can be beneficially used. Over 80 miles of trunk lines were constructed at a cost of over $140 million. It is classified as a direct reuse project, and water supplied for non-potable uses by this system can supply up to 35,000 acre-feet per year, about 20% of the volume that San Antonio currently withdraws from the Aquifer. Although reuse is encouraged by the Texas State Water Plan, the state's rules and regulations have not caught up with the 21st century, and SAWS has been unable to obtain permits from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality that would allow full utilization of the reuse system.

SAWS Recycled Water Distribution System

In addition to supplying water to customers for non-potable uses, the SAWS' project was constructed as a unique dual-use system that also involves augmenting the flow of several area waterways. As such, it is one of the largest environmental protection and enhancement projects ever conceived and constructed in the state of Texas. On the San Antonio River in the downtown area, construction of three new discharge points allowed several Edwards wells to be shut off that for many decades had been supplying all the dry-weather flow to the River Walk. A fourth discharge on Salado Creek has re-established a baseflow and created the foundation for a linear aquatic greenbelt (see the Salado Creek page). Since these discharges started, biologists have documented significant and lasting improvements to the aquatic ecosystems in both the San Antonio River and Salado Creek.


Discharge to the River Walk

Most visitors to San Antonio are unaware that during dry times, the famous River Walk is almost all recycled water from the city's treatment plants. This is one of the discharges, located adjacent to the Convention Center.


CPS pump station on the San Antonio River

These monster pumps on the San Antonio River have a combined capacity of about 98 million gallons per day.  That is about equal to the combined discharge of all of San Antonio's water recycling plants on a very dry, low-flow day.


View of San Antonio River from pump station

Flow in the San Antonio River can be greatly reduced past this point when the pumps are running.


Braunig Lake

Braunig Lake covers 1,350 acres in south Bexar county. The power plant across the lake uses wastewater effluent for cooling.


CPS power plant

Power plants owned by the City of San Antonio use over 40,000 acre-feet of recycled water during dry years that would otherwise have to be drawn from potable supplies.


Celebration of San Antonio River flow augmentation discharge

SAWS' project also involved augmenting the flow of the San Antonio River in the downtown area with recycled water so that Edwards wells supplying flow to the River Walk could be shut off.  The first discharge of recycled water occurred on March 28, 2000 near the inlet to the river flood tunnel, and it marked a historic and momentous day for the City.  On June 20 dignitaries celebrated the completion of a second discharge location in Brackenridge Park by heaving buckets of recycled water into the river (left).  Just moments before, the Edwards well in the left foreground was shut off.  For decades, this well and two others supplied the entire dry-weather flow of the San Antonio river in the River Walk area.  For more on how this water is produced, see the section on Water Recycling.


Golf course holding pond

Every single municipal golf course owned by the City of San Antonio uses recycled water for irrigation instead of fresh Edwards supplies. Here, a discharge is made to a holding pond, from which irrigation systems draw their supply.


Water Use at Fiesta Texas Theme Park

Uses such as this are prime targets for reuse and recycling projects.  Though quite aesthetically pleasing, there is really no reason that potable Edwards water has to be used.  However, since Fiesta Texas is situated over the recharge zone, and since there are pervasive negative public attitudes about moving recycled water to this area, the SAWS Recycled Water System was not constructed to reach Fiesta Texas. Recycled water is of much higher quality than the stormwater that naturally recharges the Aquifer, but public perceptions can be difficult to overcome.


Water Use at Fiesta Texas Theme Park

Another view of water use at Fiesta Texas Theme Park taken shortly after the Park opened in 1992.